Introduction

L0Learn is a fast toolkit for L0-regularized learning. L0 regularization selects the best subset of features and can outperform commonly used feature selection methods (e.g., L1 and MCP) under many sparse learning regimes. The toolkit can (approximately) solve the following three problems \[ \min_{\beta_0, \beta} \sum_{i=1}^{n} \ell(y_i, \beta_0+ \langle x_i, \beta \rangle) + \lambda ||\beta||_0 \quad \quad (L0) \] \[ \min_{\beta_0, \beta} \sum_{i=1}^{n} \ell(y_i, \beta_0+ \langle x_i, \beta \rangle) + \lambda ||\beta||_0 + \gamma||\beta||_1 \quad (L0L1) \]

\[ \min_{\beta_0, \beta} \sum_{i=1}^{n} \ell(y_i, \beta_0+ \langle x_i, \beta \rangle) + \lambda ||\beta||_0 + \gamma||\beta||_2^2 \quad (L0L2) \] where \(\ell\) is the loss function, \(\beta_0\) is the intercept, \(\beta\) is the vector of coefficients, and \(||\beta||_0\) denotes the L0 norm of \(\beta\), i.e., the number of non-zeros in \(\beta\). We support both regression and classification using either one of the following loss functions:

  • Squared error loss
  • Logistic loss (logistic regression)
  • Squared hinge loss (smoothed version of SVM).

The parameter \(\lambda\) controls the strength of the L0 regularization (larger \(\lambda\) leads to less non-zeros). The parameter \(\gamma\) controls the strength of the shrinkage component (which is the L1 norm in case of L0L1 or squared L2 norm in case of L0L2); adding a shrinkage term to L0 can be very effective in avoiding overfitting and typically leads to better predictive models. The fitting is done over a grid of \(\lambda\) and \(\gamma\) values to generate a regularization path.

The algorithms provided in L0Learn are based on cyclic coordinate descent and local combinatorial search. Many computational tricks and heuristics are used to speed up the algorithms and improve the solution quality. These heuristics include warm starts, active set convergence, correlation screening, greedy cycling order, and efficient methods for updating the residuals through exploiting sparsity and problem dimensions. Moreover, we employed a new computationally efficient method for dynamically selecting the regularization parameter \(\lambda\) in the path. For more details on the algorithms used, please refer to our paper Fast Best Subset Selection: Coordinate Descent and Local Combinatorial Optimization Algorithms.

The toolkit is implemented in C++ along with an easy-to-use R interface. In this vignette, we provide a tutorial on using the R interface. Particularly, we will demonstrate how use L0Learn’s main functions for fitting models, cross-validation, and visualization.

Installation

L0Learn can be installed directly from CRAN by executing:

install.packages("L0Learn")

If you face installation issues, please refer to the Installation Troubleshooting Wiki. If the issue is not resolved, you can submit an issue on L0Learn’s Github Repo.

Tutorial

To demonstrate how L0Learn works, we will first generate a synthetic dataset and then proceed to fitting L0-regularized models. The synthetic dataset (y,X) will be generated from a sparse linear model as follows:

  • X is a 500x1000 design matrix with iid standard normal entries
  • B is a 1000x1 vector with the first 10 entries set to 1 and the rest are zeros.
  • e is a 500x1 vector with iid standard normal entries
  • y is a 500x1 response vector such that y = XB + e

This dataset can be generated in R as follows:

set.seed(1) # fix the seed to get a reproducible result
X = matrix(rnorm(500*1000),nrow=500,ncol=1000)
B = c(rep(1,10),rep(0,990))
e = rnorm(500)
y = X%*%B + e

We will use L0Learn to estimate B from the data (y,X). First we load L0Learn:

library(L0Learn)

We will start by fitting a simple L0 model and then proceed to the case of L0L2 and L0L1.

Fitting L0 Regression Models

To fit a path of solutions for the L0-regularized model with at most 20 non-zeros using coordinate descent (CD), we use the L0Learn.fit function as follows:

fit <- L0Learn.fit(X, y, penalty="L0", maxSuppSize=20)

This will generate solutions for a sequence of \(\lambda\) values (chosen automatically by the algorithm). To view the sequence of \(\lambda\) along with the associated support sizes (i.e., the number of non-zeros), we use the print method as follows:

print(fit)
#>         lambda gamma suppSize
#> 1  0.068285500     0        0
#> 2  0.067602600     0        1
#> 3  0.055200200     0        2
#> 4  0.049032300     0        3
#> 5  0.040072500     0        6
#> 6  0.038602900     0        7
#> 7  0.037264900     0        8
#> 8  0.032514200     0       10
#> 9  0.001142920     0       11
#> 10 0.000821227     0       13
#> 11 0.000702292     0       14
#> 12 0.000669520     0       15
#> 13 0.000489938     0       17

To extract the estimated B for particular values of \(\lambda\) and \(\gamma\), we use the function coef(fit,lambda,gamma). For example, the solution at \(\lambda = 0.0325142\) (which corresponds to a support size of 10) can be extracted using

coef(fit, lambda=0.0325142, gamma=0)
#> 1001 x 1 sparse Matrix of class "dgCMatrix"
#>                     
#> Intercept 0.01052346
#> V1        1.01601401
#> V2        1.01829953
#> V3        1.00606260
#> V4        0.98308999
#> V5        0.97389545
#> V6        0.96148014
#> V7        1.00990709
#> V8        1.08535033
#> V9        1.02685765
#> V10       0.94236638
#> V11       .         
#> V12       .         
...

The output is a sparse vector of type dgCMatrix. The first element in the vector is the intercept and the rest are the B coefficients. Aside from the intercept, the only non-zeros in the above solution are coordinates 1, 2, 3, …, 10, which are the non-zero coordinates in the true support (used to generated the data). Thus, this solution successfully recovers the true support. Note that on some BLAS implementations, the lambda value we used above (i.e., 0.0325142) might be slightly different due to the limitations of numerical precision. Moreover, all the solutions in the regularization path can be extracted at once by calling coef(fit).

The sequence of \(\lambda\) generated by L0Learn is stored in the object fit. Specifically, fit$lambda is a list, where each element of the list is a sequence of \(\lambda\) values corresponding to a single value of \(\gamma\). Since L0 has only one value of \(\gamma\) (i.e., 0), we can access the sequence of \(\lambda\) values using fit$lambda[[1]]. Thus, \(\lambda=0.0325142\) we used previously can be accessed using fit$lambda[[1]][7] (since it is the 7th value in the output of print). So the previous solution can also be extracted using coef(fit,lambda=fit$lambda[[1]][7], gamma=0).

We can make predictions using a specific solution in the grid using the function predict(fit,newx,lambda,gamma) where newx is a testing sample (vector or matrix). For example, to predict the response for the samples in the data matrix X using the solution with \(\lambda=0.0325142\), we call the prediction function as follows:

predict(fit, newx=X, lambda=0.0325142, gamma=0)
#> 500 x 1 Matrix of class "dgeMatrix"
#>               [,1]
#>   [1,]  0.44584683
#>   [2,] -1.52213221
#>   [3,] -1.11755544
#>   [4,] -0.93180249
#>   [5,] -4.02095821
#>   [6,]  2.02300763
#>   [7,]  2.03371819
#>   [8,]  0.92234198
#>   [9,]  2.33359737
#>  [10,]  0.92194909
#>  [11,] -4.33165265
#>  [12,] -2.13282518
#>  [13,] -7.21962511
...

We can also visualize the regularization path by plotting the coefficients of the estimated B versus the support size (i.e., the number of non-zeros) using the plot(fit,gamma) method as follows:

plot(fit, gamma=0)

The legend of the plot presents the variables in the order they entered the regularization path. For example, variable 7 is the first variable to enter the path, and variable 6 is the second to enter. Thus, roughly speaking, we can view the first \(k\) variables in the legend as the best subset of size \(k\). To show the lines connecting the points in the plot, we can set the parameter showLines=TRUE in the plot function, i.e., call plot(fit, gamma=0, showLines=TRUE). Moreover, we note that the output of the plot function above is a ggplot object, which can be further customized using the ggplot2 package.

Fitting L0L2 and L0L1 Regression Models

We have demonstrated the simple case of using an L0 penalty. We can also fit more elaborate models that combine L0 regularization with shrinkage-inducing penalties like the L1 norm or squared L2 norm. Adding shrinkage helps in avoiding overfitting and typically improves the predictive performance of the models. Next, we will discuss how to fit a model using the L0L2 penalty for a two-dimensional grid of \(\lambda\) and \(\gamma\) values. Recall that by default, L0Learn automatically selects the \(\lambda\) sequence, so we only need to specify the \(\gamma\) sequence. Suppose we want to fit an L0L2 model with a maximum of 20 non-zeros and a sequence of 5 \(\gamma\) values ranging between 0.0001 and 10. We can do so by calling L0Learn.fit with penalty="L0L2", nGamma=5, gammaMin=0.0001, and gammaMax=10 as follows:

fit <- L0Learn.fit(X, y, penalty="L0L2", nGamma = 5, gammaMin = 0.0001, gammaMax = 10, maxSuppSize=20)

L0Learn will generate a grid of 5 \(\gamma\) values equi-spaced on the logarithmic scale between 0.0001 and 10. Similar to the case of L0, we can print a summary of the regularization path using the print function as follows:

print(fit)
#>          lambda        gamma suppSize
#> 1   0.003251690 10.000000000        0
#> 2   0.003219170 10.000000000        1
#> 3   0.002776000 10.000000000        2
#> 4   0.002687010 10.000000000        3
#> 5   0.002577800 10.000000000        3
#> 6   0.002062240 10.000000000        6
#> 7   0.001861720 10.000000000        7
#> 8   0.001710400 10.000000000        8
#> 9   0.001644570 10.000000000        9
#> 10  0.001153900 10.000000000       10
#> 11  0.000482462 10.000000000       10
#> 12  0.000385970 10.000000000       12
#> 13  0.000374391 10.000000000       14
#> 14  0.000363159 10.000000000       15
#> 15  0.000352264 10.000000000       15
#> 16  0.000281811 10.000000000       19
#> 17  0.000273357 10.000000000       19
#> 18  0.032139100  0.562341325        0
#> 19  0.031817800  0.562341325        1
#> 20  0.027437500  0.562341325        1
#> 21  0.021950000  0.562341325        4
#> 22  0.021291500  0.562341325        4
#> 23  0.017033200  0.562341325        9
#> 24  0.011404900  0.562341325       10
#> 25  0.004768580  0.562341325       10
#> 26  0.003814860  0.562341325       10
#> 27  0.003051890  0.562341325       10
#> 28  0.002441510  0.562341325       10
#> 29  0.001953210  0.562341325       10
...

The sequence of \(\gamma\) values can be accessed using fit$gamma. To extract a solution we use the coef method. For example, extracting the solution at \(\lambda=0.0011539\) and \(\gamma=10\) can be done using

coef(fit,lambda=0.0011539, gamma=10)
#> 1001 x 1 sparse Matrix of class "dgCMatrix"
#>                      
#> Intercept -0.02424084
#> V1         0.04267751
#> V2         0.04765638
#> V3         0.04958919
#> V4         0.05100251
#> V5         0.04411968
#> V6         0.05385520
#> V7         0.05597895
#> V8         0.04374915
#> V9         0.05429957
#> V10        0.03644110
#> V11        .         
#> V12        .         
...

Similarly, we can predict the response at this pair of \(\lambda\) and \(\gamma\) for the matrix X using

predict(fit, newx=X, lambda=0.0011539, gamma=10)

The regularization path can also be plot at a specific \(\gamma\) using plot(fit, gamma). Finally, we note that fitting an L0L1 model can be done by just changing the penalty to “L0L1” in the above (in this case gammaMax will be ignored since it is automatically selected by the toolkit; see the reference manual for more details.)

Cross-validation

We will demonstrate how to use K-fold cross-validation (CV) to select the optimal values of the tuning parameters \(\lambda\) and \(\gamma\). To perform CV, we use the L0Learn.cvfit function, which takes the same parameters as L0Learn.fit, in addition to the number of folds using the nFolds parameter and a seed value using the seed parameter (this is used when randomly shuffling the data before performing CV).

For example, to perform 5-fold CV using the L0L2 penalty (over a range of 5 gamma values between 0.0001 and 0.1) with a maximum of 50 non-zeros, we run:

cvfit = L0Learn.cvfit(X, y, nFolds=5, seed=1, penalty="L0L2", nGamma=5, gammaMin=0.0001, gammaMax=0.1, maxSuppSize=50)

Note that the object cvfit has a member fit (accessed using cvfit$fit) which is output of running L0Learn.fit on (y,X). The cross-validation errors can be accessed using the cvMeans attribute of cvfit: cvfit$cvMeans is a list where the ith element, cvfit$cvMeans[[i]], stores the cross-validation errors for the ith value of gamma (cvfit$fit$gamma[i]). To find the minimum cross-validation error for every gamma, we call the min function for every element in the list cvfit$cvMeans, as follows:

lapply(cvfit$cvMeans, min)
#> [[1]]
#> [1] 1.283026
#> 
#> [[2]]
#> [1] 1.000699
#> 
#> [[3]]
#> [1] 0.9900166
#> 
#> [[4]]
#> [1] 0.9899541
#> 
#> [[5]]
#> [1] 0.9900055

The above output indicates that the 4th value of gamma achieves the lowest CV error (=0.9899542). We can plot the CV errors against the support size for the 4th value of gamma, i.e., gamma = cvfit$fit$gamma[4], using:

plot(cvfit, gamma=cvfit$fit$gamma[4])

The above plot is produced using the ggplot2 package and can be further customized by the user. To extract the optimal \(\lambda\) (i.e., the one with minimum CV error) in this plot, we execute the following:

optimalGammaIndex = 4 # index of the optimal gamma identified previously
optimalLambdaIndex = which.min(cvfit$cvMeans[[optimalGammaIndex]])
optimalLambda = cvfit$fit$lambda[[optimalGammaIndex]][optimalLambdaIndex]
optimalLambda
#> [1] 0.00809626

To print the solution corresponding to the optimal gamma/lambda pair:

coef(cvfit, lambda=optimalLambda, gamma=cvfit$fit$gamma[4])
#> 1001 x 1 sparse Matrix of class "dgCMatrix"
#>                     
#> Intercept 0.01044999
#> V1        1.01472611
#> V2        1.01711155
#> V3        1.00494630
#> V4        0.98208003
#> V5        0.97274703
#> V6        0.96057359
#> V7        1.00895157
#> V8        1.08392099
#> V9        1.02580620
#> V10       0.94108163
#> V11       .         
#> V12       .         
...

The optimal solution (above) selected by cross-validation correctly recovers the support of the true vector of coefficients used to generated the model.

Fitting Classification Models

All the commands and plots we have seen in the case of regression extend to classification. We currently support logistic regression (using the parameter loss = "Logistic") and a smoothed version of SVM (using the parameter loss="SquaredHinge"). To give some examples, we first generate a synthetic classification dataset (similar to the one we generated in the case of regression):

set.seed(1) # fix the seed to get a reproducible result
X = matrix(rnorm(500*1000),nrow=500,ncol=1000)
B = c(rep(1,10),rep(0,990))
e = rnorm(500)
y = sign(X%*%B + e)

An L0-regularized logistic regression model can be fit by specificying loss = "Logistic" as follows:

fit = L0Learn.fit(X,y,loss="Logistic")
print(fit)
#>          lambda gamma suppSize
#> 1   2.03415e+01 1e-07        1
#> 2   1.82815e+01 1e-07        2
#> 3   1.80478e+01 1e-07        2
#> 4   1.44382e+01 1e-07        5
#> 5   1.40051e+01 1e-07        5
#> 6   1.12041e+01 1e-07        7
#> 7   1.08679e+01 1e-07        7
#> 8   8.69435e+00 1e-07       10
#> 9   4.45223e+00 1e-07       10
#> 10  3.56178e+00 1e-07       10
#> 11  2.84943e+00 1e-07       10
#> 12  2.27954e+00 1e-07       10
#> 13  1.82363e+00 1e-07       10
#> 14  1.45891e+00 1e-07       10
...

The output above indicates that \(\gamma=10^{-7}\)—by default we use a small ridge regularization (with \(\gamma=10^{-7}\)) to ensure the existence of a solution. To extract the coefficients of the solution with \(\lambda = 8.69435\):

coef(fit, lambda=8.69435, gamma=1e-7)
#> 1001 x 1 sparse Matrix of class "dgCMatrix"
#>                     
#> Intercept -0.1797751
#> V1         2.0617431
#> V2         2.2437744
#> V3         1.9869710
#> V4         2.1627060
#> V5         2.1201722
#> V6         2.1177628
#> V7         1.8449653
#> V8         2.4375011
#> V9         2.3808994
#> V10        2.1134238
#> V11        .        
#> V12        .        
...

The above indicates that the 10 non-zeros in the estimated model match those we used in generating the data (i.e, L0 regularization correctly recovered the true support). We can also make predictions at the latter \(\lambda\) using:

predict(fit, newx=X, lambda=8.69435, gamma=1e-7)
#> 500 x 1 Matrix of class "dgeMatrix"
#>                [,1]
#>   [1,] 5.786002e-01
#>   [2,] 2.067591e-02
#>   [3,] 5.357189e-02
#>   [4,] 7.589991e-02
#>   [5,] 1.460869e-04
#>   [6,] 9.886345e-01
#>   [7,] 9.620193e-01
#>   [8,] 9.201535e-01
#>   [9,] 9.912170e-01
#>  [10,] 7.672292e-01
#>  [11,] 3.756393e-05
#>  [12,] 5.631011e-03
#>  [13,] 2.491432e-07
...

Each row in the above is the probability that the corresponding sample belongs to class \(1\). Other models (i.e., L0L2 and L0L1) can be similarly fit by specifying loss = "Logistic".

Finally, we note that L0Learn also supports a smoothed version of SVM by using squared hinge loss (loss = "SquaredHinge"). The only difference from logistic regression is that the predict function returns \(\beta_0 + \langle x, \beta \rangle\) (where \(x\) is the testing sample), instead of returning probabilities. The latter predictions can be assigned to the appropriate classes by using a thresholding function (e.g., the sign function).

Advanced Options

Sparse Matrix Support

Starting in version 2.0.0, L0Learn supports sparse matrices of type dgCMatrix. If your sparse matrix uses a different storage format, please convert it to dgCMatrix before using it in L0Learn. L0Learn keeps the matrix sparse internally and thus is highly efficient if the matrix is sufficiently sparse. The API for sparse matrices is the same as that of dense matrices, so all the demonstrations in this vignette also apply for sparse matrices. For example, we can fit an L0-regularized model on a sparse matrix as follows:

# As an example, we generate a random, sparse matrix with 
# 500 samples, 1000 features, and 10% nonzero entries.
X_sparse <- Matrix::rsparsematrix(nrow=500, ncol=1000, density=0.1, rand.x = rnorm)
# Below we generate the response using the same linear model as before,
# but with the sparse data matrix X_sparse.
y_sparseX <- as.vector(X_sparse%*%B + e)

# Call L0Learn.
fit_sparse <- L0Learn.fit(X_sparse, y_sparseX, penalty="L0")

# Note: In the setup above, X_sparse is of type dgCMatrix.
# If your sparse matrix is of a different type, convert it 
# to dgCMatrix before calling L0Learn, e.g., using: X_sparse <- as(X_sparse, "dgCMatrix").

Selection on Subset of Variables

In certain applications, it is desirable to always include some of the variables in the model and perform variable selection on others. L0Learn supports this option through the excludeFirstK parameter. Specifically, setting excludeFirstK = K (where K is a non-negative integer) instructs L0Learn to exclude the first K variables in the data matrix X from the L0-norm penalty (those K variables will still be penalized using the L2 or L1 norm penalties.). For example, below we fit an L0 model and exclude the first 3 variables from selection by setting excludeFirstK = 3:

fit <- L0Learn.fit(X, y, penalty="L0", maxSuppSize=10, excludeFirstK=3)

Plotting the regularization path:

plot(fit, gamma=0)

We can see in the plot above that first 3 variables are included in all the solutions of the path.

Coefficient Bounds

Starting in version 2.0.0, L0Learn supports bounds for CD algorithms for all losses and penalties. (We plan to support bound constraints for the CDPSI algorithm in the future). By default, L0Learn does not apply bounds, i.e., it assumes \(-\infty <= \beta_i <= \infty\) for all i. Users can supply the same bounds for all coefficients by setting the parameters lows and highs to scalar values (these should satisfy: lows <= 0, lows != highs, and highs >= 0). To use different bounds for the coefficients, lows and highs can be both set to vectors of length p (where the i-th entry corresponds to the bound on coefficient i).

All of the following examples are valid.

L0Learn.fit(X, y, penalty="L0", lows=-0.5)
L0Learn.fit(X, y, penalty="L0", highs=0.5)
L0Learn.fit(X, y, penalty="L0", lows=-0.5, highs=0.5)
low_vector <- c(rep(-0.1, 500), rep(-0.125, 500))
fit <- L0Learn.fit(X, y, penalty="L0", lows=low_vector, highs=0.25)

We can see the coefficients are subject to the bounds.

print(max(fit$beta[[1]]))
#> [1] 0.25
print(min(fit$beta[[1]][1:500, ]))
#> [1] -0.1
print(min(fit$beta[[1]][501:1000, ]))
#> [1] -0.1222599

User-specified Lambda Grids

By default, L0Learn selects the sequence of lambda values in an efficient manner to avoid wasted computation (since close \(\lambda\) values can typically lead to the same solution). Advanced users of the toolkit can change this default behavior and supply their own sequence of \(\lambda\) values. This can be done supplying the \(\lambda\) values through the parameter lambdaGrid. L0Learn versions before 2.0.0 would also require setting the autoLambda parameter to FALSE. This parameter remains in version 2.0.0 for backwards compatibility, but is no longer needed or used.

Specifically, the value assigned to lambdaGrid should be a list of lists of decreasing positive values (doubles). The length of lambdaGrid (the number of lists stored) specifies the number of gamma parameters that will fill between gammaMin, and gammaMax. In the case of L0 penalty, lambdaGrid must be a list of length 1. In case of L0L2/L0L1 lambdaGrid can have any number of sub-lists stored. The length of lambdaGrid (the number of lists stored) specifies the number of gamma parameters that will fill between gammaMin, and gammaMax. The ith element in LambdaGrid should be a decreasing sequence of positive lambda values which are used by the algorithm for the ith value of gamma. For example, to fit an L0 model with the sequence of user-specified lambda values: 1, 1e-1, 1e-2, 1e-3, 1e-4, we run the following:

userLambda <- list()
userLambda[[1]] <- c(1, 1e-1, 1e-2, 1e-3, 1e-4)
fit <- L0Learn.fit(X, y, penalty="L0", lambdaGrid=userLambda, maxSuppSize=1000)

To verify the results we print the fit object:

print(fit)
#>   lambda gamma suppSize
#> 1  1e+00     0        0
#> 2  1e-01     0        0
#> 3  1e-02     0       10
#> 4  1e-03     0       62
#> 5  1e-04     0      257

Note that the \(\lambda\) values above are the desired values. For L0L2 and L0L1 penalties, the same can be done where the lambdaGrid parameter.

userLambda <- list()
userLambda[[1]] <- c(1, 1e-1, 1e-2, 1e-3, 1e-4)
userLambda[[2]] <- c(10, 2, 1, 0.01, 0.002, 0.001, 1e-5) 
userLambda[[3]] <- c(1e-4, 1e-5) 
# userLambda[[i]] must be a vector of positive decreasing reals.
fit <- L0Learn.fit(X, y, penalty="L0L2", lambdaGrid=userLambda, maxSuppSize=1000)
print(fit)
#>    lambda       gamma suppSize
#> 1   1e+00 10.00000000        0
#> 2   1e-01 10.00000000        0
#> 3   1e-02 10.00000000        0
#> 4   1e-03 10.00000000        8
#> 5   1e-04 10.00000000      132
#> 6   1e+01  0.03162278        0
#> 7   2e+00  0.03162278        0
#> 8   1e+00  0.03162278        0
#> 9   1e-02  0.03162278       10
#> 10  2e-03  0.03162278       26
#> 11  1e-03  0.03162278       65
#> 12  1e-05  0.03162278      625
#> 13  1e-04  0.00010000      311
#> 14  1e-05  0.00010000      409

References

Hussein Hazimeh and Rahul Mazumder. Fast Best Subset Selection: Coordinate Descent and Local Combinatorial Optimization Algorithms. Operations Research (2020).

Antoine Dedieu, Hussein Hazimeh, and Rahul Mazumder. Learning Sparse Classifiers: Continuous and Mixed Integer Optimization Perspectives. JMLR (to appear).